Key Tips for Jordanelle Real Estate Buyers from Locals
Key Tips for Jordanelle Real Estate Buyers from Locals
Let’s cut through the noise. Lodge at Stillwater has moved 6 units between October 2024 and April 2025—that’s consistent momentum in a market where plenty of properties are collecting dust. But here’s what the raw numbers actually tell us about timing, value, and whether you should make a move.
Recent transactions show a clear divide: properly priced units move, overpriced ones don’t. Three properties hit their exact asking price (100% list-to-sale ratio), while others that lingered got reality checks. The $510K unit that sold in December? Gone in 9 days. Meanwhile, we’ve got active listings that have been sitting since February because someone got a little too optimistic with their pricing.
This isn’t panic buying or a frenzy market—it’s informed buyers recognizing when the numbers make sense. The sweet spot seems to be that $600K-$750K range for 1-2 bed units, with the larger 2-bed/3-bath units commanding $850K+.
Here’s the thing about rebrands—they’re only as good as the execution behind them. The Lodge at Stillwater transformation to “The Mason” does create a legitimate window. You’re buying at current pricing while betting on future improvements, plus 60 new units coming online that should juice the overall property appeal.
Recent sales show units with 2023-2024 renovations already done, so you can see exactly what “Mason quality” looks like. No guessing games. The risk-reward math favors early movers, but only if you pick the right unit at the right time. Construction noise and timing disruption vary wildly depending on where you land in the complex.
While other Jordanelle properties pile up inventory, Lodge at Stillwater maintains that sweet supply-demand tension. The rental-friendly HOA policies and reasonable fees attract a specific buyer profile: people who want Deer Valley access without the Deer Valley price tag, and the flexibility to offset their investment with nightly rentals.
New construction costs have pushed comparable properties well north of Lodge at Stillwater’s range. When you can grab a renovated 2-bedroom for $750K that would cost $1.2M+ to build new, the value gap becomes pretty obvious.
Higher interest rates have cleared out the speculators and weekend warriors. What’s left are serious buyers with substantial down payments or cash positions who can actually close. This means less bidding war drama and more room for smart negotiation.
The rental income potential helps serious investors make the numbers work even with higher carrying costs. And cash buyers—who represent a significant chunk of Park City transactions—find particular value in the property’s proven cash-flow track record.
Deer Valley’s East Village expansion and ongoing Jordanelle development will likely boost property values long-term, but they’ll also bring traffic, crowds, and the general chaos of a construction zone. Buying now means you secure established 3-minute gondola access before the area gets more complicated.
That gondola connection becomes increasingly valuable as parking and access get tighter with development pressure. Sometimes getting in early at a proven location beats waiting for “perfect” timing that never materializes.
Rising renovation costs mean future Mason-branded listings will command premium pricing. Limited rental-friendly inventory as more HOAs crack down on short-term rentals. Development pressure increases competition for prime Jordanelle locations. Proven demand from recent sales shows consistent buyer recognition of value.
The combination of current pricing, renovation timing, rental policies, and location advantages creates a narrow window. Perfect market timing doesn’t exist, but current conditions favor buyers who know what they’re looking for.
We’ve been working Park City real estate for over 25 years and live 5 minutes from the Jordanelle. That means we know which units offer the strongest rental potential, which renovations are actually worth paying for, and which represent the best value in today’s market.
What we bring: Real renovation timelines, actual booking data from current owners, connections with proven property managers, and the insight to structure offers that get accepted while protecting your interests.
What you get: No-pressure conversation about your goals, honest assessment of whether Lodge at Stillwater fits your situation, and access to listings before they hit the public market.
Ready to see what the smart money is buying? Let’s schedule your Lodge at Stillwater tour this week.
Contact the Keye Team: 801-550-4022 or jeff@keyeteam.com
We send out regular Park City real estate market reports, along with cultural events, local information, and more.